🛠 IN-FLIGHT
20260530-replicate-body-multiface-v1
No SUMMARY.md in this run dir. An operator landing here can't tell what the run was about without digging through the files below. To fix, drop a
SUMMARY.md following the template.
Images (14)
Data (1)
manifest.json
{
"sweep": "replicate-body-multiface-v1",
"date": "2026-05-30T00:57:46.688966",
"goal": "Replicate-side identity-preserving body sweep on same fixtures as fal v2.",
"faces": [
{
"id": "FA",
"desc": "blonde woman, mid-20s, light eyes, white tank (cropped from webapp marketing fixture preview-models.jpg)",
"path": "/Users/claude/Projects/ikatomi-workspace/ikatomi-labs/runs/20260530-identity-body-multiface-v1/face_source_a.jpeg"
},
{
"id": "FB",
"desc": "brown-haired man, mid-30s, light eyes, fair skin, grey tee (cropped from webapp marketing fixture preview-pants.jpg)",
"path": "/Users/claude/Projects/ikatomi-workspace/ikatomi-labs/runs/20260530-identity-body-multiface-v1/face_source_b.jpeg"
}
],
"prompts": [
{
"id": "P0-front-full",
"prompt": "Full-body professional model standing in a neutral pose, front view, clean light grey studio background, photorealistic, sharp focus, soft studio lighting, wearing a plain white tank top and grey shorts."
},
{
"id": "P2-upper-front",
"prompt": "Upper body portrait of a professional model, head and shoulders framing, front view, clean light grey studio background, photorealistic, soft studio lighting, wearing a plain white tank top."
}
],
"seeds": [
42,
7301,
19023
],
"vendors": [
{
"name": "RPL-PULID",
"endpoint": "bytedance/pulid:43d309c37ab4e62361e5e29b8e9e867fb2dcbcec77ae91206a8d95ac5dd451a0",
"usd_per_call": 0.005,
"notes": "bytedance/pulid (PuLID-FLUX). id_weight=1.05 (slightly above fal's 1.0 default). 20\u00d7 cheaper than fal-ai/flux-pulid for the same underlying model."
},
{
"name": "RPL-INSTID",
"endpoint": "grandlineai/instant-id-photorealistic",
"usd_per_call": 0.082,
"notes": "InstantID photorealistic. Different architecture from PuLID (ControlNet-style face conditioning). Higher per-call cost; different failure modes worth testing."
}
],
"judge_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6",
"judge_axes": [
"face_is_source_identity",
"body_framing_matches_prompt",
"clean_studio_bg",
"looks_photographic"
],
"pass_bars": {
"per_cell": "all 4 axes = Y",
"per_vendor": ">= 75% pass rate"
},
"outcomes": [
{
"vendor": "RPL-PULID",
"endpoint": "bytedance/pulid:43d309c37ab4e62361e5e29b8e9e867fb2dcbcec77ae91206a8d95ac5dd451a0",
"pass_count": 0,
"total_cells": 12,
"pass_rate": 0.0,
"proceeds": false,
"fal_cost": 0.05999999999999999,
"judge_in_tokens": 19590,
"judge_out_tokens": 947,
"judge_usd": 0.072975,
"judges": [
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S42",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 42,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": true,
"axes_passed": 3,
"verdict": "fail: Q1",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The rendered face shows a shorter-haired, slightly different facial structure and jawline that does not convincingly match the source reference's longer-haired, softer-featured identity.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S42.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S7301",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 7301,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": true,
"axes_passed": 3,
"verdict": "fail: Q1",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The rendered face has shorter hair, blue eyes, and different facial structure compared to the reference's longer wavy blonde hair, green/hazel eyes, and distinct jawline.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S7301.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S19023",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 19023,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": true,
"axes_passed": 2,
"verdict": "fail: Q1, Q2",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The render shows a different person (shorter bob hair, different facial structure/eye color) and the body is cropped at mid-thigh with feet not visible, failing both identity preservation and full-body framing requirements.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S19023.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S42",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 42,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 2,
"verdict": "fail: Q1, Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The render shows a different person with shorter hair, blue eyes, a narrower face, and overly smooth/plasticky skin that does not match the source identity.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S42.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S7301",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 7301,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 2,
"verdict": "fail: Q1, Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The render shows a different person with darker, shorter hair, heavier brows, and a more angular face than the source, and the image has a plasticky AI-render quality with overly smooth skin and artificial catchlights.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S7301.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S19023",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 19023,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 1,
"verdict": "fail: Q1, Q2, Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The render shows a different person (shorter hair, different facial structure, more angular features) posed at a 3/4 angle rather than front view, with an over-smoothed, plasticky AI aesthetic.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S19023.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S42",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 42,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 2,
"verdict": "fail: Q1, Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The rendered figure has a noticeably thinner, younger face with a different jaw and bone structure than the reference, and the image has a plasticky, over-smoothed AI-render quality rather than a photographic look.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S42.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S7301",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 7301,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 2,
"verdict": "fail: Q1, Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The rendered face is a different, more youthful and plasticky-looking person with notably different facial structure and blue eyes, unlike the reference's darker, deeper-set features, and the overall image has an AI-render quality rather than photographic realism.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S7301.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S19023",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 19023,
"face_is_source_identity": true,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 2,
"verdict": "fail: Q2, Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The render cuts off at mid-thigh with feet not visible, and the skin and overall image have a plasticky, over-smoothed AI appearance rather than a photographic look.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S19023.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S42",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 42,
"face_is_source_identity": true,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 3,
"verdict": "fail: Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The skin has an overly smooth, plasticky quality with artificially perfect lighting that makes the render look like a CGI model rather than a real photograph.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S42.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S7301",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 7301,
"face_is_source_identity": true,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 3,
"verdict": "fail: Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The render has plasticky, over-smoothed skin with an artificial sheen and overly symmetrical lighting that makes it look like a CGI illustration rather than a real photograph.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S7301.png"
},
{
"label": "RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S19023",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 19023,
"face_is_source_identity": true,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": true,
"clean_studio_bg": true,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 3,
"verdict": "fail: Q4",
"ok": false,
"observation": "The skin has an overly smooth, plasticky appearance with artificial sheen typical of AI renders rather than a real photograph.",
"image_path": "RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S19023.png"
}
],
"render_errors": []
},
{
"vendor": "RPL-INSTID",
"endpoint": "grandlineai/instant-id-photorealistic",
"pass_count": 0,
"total_cells": 12,
"pass_rate": 0.0,
"proceeds": false,
"fal_cost": 0.0,
"judge_in_tokens": 0,
"judge_out_tokens": 0,
"judge_usd": 0.0,
"judges": [
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S42",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 42,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S7301",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 7301,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S19023",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 19023,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S42",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 42,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 404\ndetail: Th",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S7301",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 7301,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S19023",
"face_id": "FA",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 19023,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S42",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 42,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S7301",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 7301,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S19023",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P0-front-full",
"seed": 19023,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S42",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 42,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S7301",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 7301,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Re",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S19023",
"face_id": "FB",
"prompt_id": "P2-upper-front",
"seed": 19023,
"face_is_source_identity": false,
"body_framing_matches_prompt": false,
"clean_studio_bg": false,
"looks_photographic": false,
"axes_passed": 0,
"verdict": "render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 404\ndetail: Th",
"ok": false,
"observation": "render failed \u2014 not judged",
"image_path": null
}
],
"render_errors": [
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S42",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~5s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S7301",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~7s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S19023",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~8s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S42",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 404\ndetail: The requested resource could not be found."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S7301",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~1s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S19023",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~5s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S42",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~6s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S7301",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~6s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S19023",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~7s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S42",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~7s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S7301",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 429\ndetail: Request was throttled. Your rate limit for creating predictions is reduced to 6 requests per minute with a burst of 1 requests while you have less than $5.0 in credit. Your rate limit resets in ~8s."
},
{
"label": "RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S19023",
"error": "replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details:\nstatus: 404\ndetail: The requested resource could not be found."
}
]
}
],
"winner": null,
"total_cost_usd": 0.13297499999999998
}
Notes (1)
RECOMMENDATION.md
# Replicate identity-body MULTI-FACE sweep — Verdict: ESCALATE — no Replicate vendor reached the 75% multi-face bar **Run**: `20260530-replicate-body-multiface-v1/` **Date**: 2026-05-30T00:57:46.687988 **Faces**: 2 (FA blonde-W / FB brown-haired-M) **Framings**: ['P0-front-full', 'P2-upper-front'] (back-view dropped — degenerate) **Seeds**: [42, 7301, 19023] **Vendors**: ['RPL-PULID', 'RPL-INSTID'] **Matrix per vendor**: 2 × 2 × 3 = 12 **Cost**: $0.13 (cap $4.00) **Judge**: `claude-sonnet-4-6` **PROCEED bar**: ≥ 75% (≥ 9/12) ## Per-vendor results | Vendor | Model | Pass (4/4) | Face-ID | Framing | Pass rate | Proceeds | $ | |--------|-------|-----------:|--------:|--------:|----------:|:--------:|---:| | RPL-PULID | `bytedance/pulid` | 0/12 | 4/12 | 9/12 | 0% | no | $0.13 | | RPL-INSTID | `grandlineai/instant-id-photorealistic` | 0/12 | 0/12 | 0/12 | 0% | no | $0.00 | ## Per-face × per-vendor face-identity | Face | RPL-PULID | RPL-INSTID | |------|:-----:|:-----:| | FA | 0/6 (0%) | 0/6 (0%) | | FB | 4/6 (67%) | 0/6 (0%) | ## Per-cell breakdown | Cell | Vendor | Face | Framing | Seed | face_id | framing | bg | photo | axes/4 | ok | |------|--------|------|---------|-----:|:-------:|:-------:|:--:|:-----:|:------:|:--:| | RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S42 | RPL-PULID | FA | P0-front-full | 42 | N | Y | Y | Y | 3/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S7301 | RPL-PULID | FA | P0-front-full | 7301 | N | Y | Y | Y | 3/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S19023 | RPL-PULID | FA | P0-front-full | 19023 | N | N | Y | Y | 2/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S42 | RPL-PULID | FA | P2-upper-front | 42 | N | Y | Y | N | 2/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S7301 | RPL-PULID | FA | P2-upper-front | 7301 | N | Y | Y | N | 2/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S19023 | RPL-PULID | FA | P2-upper-front | 19023 | N | N | Y | N | 1/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S42 | RPL-PULID | FB | P0-front-full | 42 | N | Y | Y | N | 2/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S7301 | RPL-PULID | FB | P0-front-full | 7301 | N | Y | Y | N | 2/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S19023 | RPL-PULID | FB | P0-front-full | 19023 | Y | N | Y | N | 2/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S42 | RPL-PULID | FB | P2-upper-front | 42 | Y | Y | Y | N | 3/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S7301 | RPL-PULID | FB | P2-upper-front | 7301 | Y | Y | Y | N | 3/4 | N | | RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S19023 | RPL-PULID | FB | P2-upper-front | 19023 | Y | Y | Y | N | 3/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S42 | RPL-INSTID | FA | P0-front-full | 42 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S7301 | RPL-INSTID | FA | P0-front-full | 7301 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S19023 | RPL-INSTID | FA | P0-front-full | 19023 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S42 | RPL-INSTID | FA | P2-upper-front | 42 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S7301 | RPL-INSTID | FA | P2-upper-front | 7301 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S19023 | RPL-INSTID | FA | P2-upper-front | 19023 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S42 | RPL-INSTID | FB | P0-front-full | 42 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S7301 | RPL-INSTID | FB | P0-front-full | 7301 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S19023 | RPL-INSTID | FB | P0-front-full | 19023 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S42 | RPL-INSTID | FB | P2-upper-front | 42 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S7301 | RPL-INSTID | FB | P2-upper-front | 7301 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | | RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S19023 | RPL-INSTID | FB | P2-upper-front | 19023 | N | N | N | N | 0/4 | N | ## Judge observations ### RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S42 — axes 3/4 — fail: Q1 The rendered face shows a shorter-haired, slightly different facial structure and jawline that does not convincingly match the source reference's longer-haired, softer-featured identity. ### RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S7301 — axes 3/4 — fail: Q1 The rendered face has shorter hair, blue eyes, and different facial structure compared to the reference's longer wavy blonde hair, green/hazel eyes, and distinct jawline. ### RPL-PULID-FA-P0-front-full-S19023 — axes 2/4 — fail: Q1, Q2 The render shows a different person (shorter bob hair, different facial structure/eye color) and the body is cropped at mid-thigh with feet not visible, failing both identity preservation and full-body framing requirements. ### RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S42 — axes 2/4 — fail: Q1, Q4 The render shows a different person with shorter hair, blue eyes, a narrower face, and overly smooth/plasticky skin that does not match the source identity. ### RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S7301 — axes 2/4 — fail: Q1, Q4 The render shows a different person with darker, shorter hair, heavier brows, and a more angular face than the source, and the image has a plasticky AI-render quality with overly smooth skin and artificial catchlights. ### RPL-PULID-FA-P2-upper-front-S19023 — axes 1/4 — fail: Q1, Q2, Q4 The render shows a different person (shorter hair, different facial structure, more angular features) posed at a 3/4 angle rather than front view, with an over-smoothed, plasticky AI aesthetic. ### RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S42 — axes 2/4 — fail: Q1, Q4 The rendered figure has a noticeably thinner, younger face with a different jaw and bone structure than the reference, and the image has a plasticky, over-smoothed AI-render quality rather than a photographic look. ### RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S7301 — axes 2/4 — fail: Q1, Q4 The rendered face is a different, more youthful and plasticky-looking person with notably different facial structure and blue eyes, unlike the reference's darker, deeper-set features, and the overall image has an AI-render quality rather than photographic realism. ### RPL-PULID-FB-P0-front-full-S19023 — axes 2/4 — fail: Q2, Q4 The render cuts off at mid-thigh with feet not visible, and the skin and overall image have a plasticky, over-smoothed AI appearance rather than a photographic look. ### RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S42 — axes 3/4 — fail: Q4 The skin has an overly smooth, plasticky quality with artificially perfect lighting that makes the render look like a CGI model rather than a real photograph. ### RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S7301 — axes 3/4 — fail: Q4 The render has plasticky, over-smoothed skin with an artificial sheen and overly symmetrical lighting that makes it look like a CGI illustration rather than a real photograph. ### RPL-PULID-FB-P2-upper-front-S19023 — axes 3/4 — fail: Q4 The skin has an overly smooth, plasticky appearance with artificial sheen typical of AI renders rather than a real photograph. ### RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S42 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S7301 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FA-P0-front-full-S19023 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S42 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 404 detail: Th render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S7301 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FA-P2-upper-front-S19023 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S42 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S7301 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FB-P0-front-full-S19023 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S42 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S7301 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 429 detail: Re render failed — not judged ### RPL-INSTID-FB-P2-upper-front-S19023 — axes 0/4 — render_failed: replicate run (after 3 attempts): ReplicateError Details: status: 404 detail: Th render failed — not judged --- _Per `feedback_labs_results_need_thor_review_before_port` — DO NOT port to webapp until Thor reviews this RECOMMENDATION.md and explicitly directs._